Skip to content
GableGreens

Garden & Outdoor

Topsoil vs Compost vs Garden Soil: What Is the Difference?

Topsoil gives bulk and structure, compost feeds, garden soil is a blend of both, and potting mix is for containers. Learn which to buy for each job.

Save to Pinterest (opens Pinterest in a new tab)

Illustration of three open bags of topsoil, compost and garden soil on a potting bench with a trowel

Skip the arithmetic. Enter your measurements and get quantities in imperial or metric units.

Open the Topsoil Calculator

The bags look alike, but they do different jobs. Buying the wrong one is a common reason a new bed drains badly or plants struggle.

Quick comparison

Product What it is Use it for Do not use it for
Topsoil The upper layer of natural soil: sand, silt, clay and some organic matter Raising levels, filling beds, laying lawns Pots and containers
Compost Decomposed plant material Mixing into soil, mulching, feeding beds Filling a bed on its own
Garden soil Topsoil already blended with compost Planting in the ground and in raised beds Pots and containers
Potting mix A light, soil-free blend, often based on peat-free fibre or bark Pots, tubs, hanging baskets Filling large beds (costly and too light)

Topsoil

Topsoil provides weight, structure and the mineral part of soil. Quality varies a lot. Good topsoil is dark, crumbly and free of rubble and weed roots. In the UK, look for soil sold to British Standard BS 3882. Elsewhere, ask whether it has been screened and what size it is screened to.

Compost

Compost adds organic matter, helps sandy soil hold water and helps clay soil drain. It is an ingredient, not a growing medium for a whole bed: on its own it shrinks as it continues to break down, and it can hold too much water around roots.

Garden soil

This is the convenient option for a single bed: topsoil and compost mixed for you. It costs more per unit of volume than buying the two separately, so for several beds, blending your own is usually cheaper.

Potting mix

Containers need a mix that drains fast and stays airy. Real soil in a pot packs down and stays wet. That is why potting mix contains no soil at all, and why it is the wrong product for filling a garden bed.

Which to buy

  • New raised bed: topsoil and compost blended, or bagged garden soil.
  • New lawn: screened topsoil, 4 to 6 inches (10 to 15 cm).
  • Tired existing border: 1 to 2 inches (2.5 to 5 cm) of compost on top each year.
  • Pots and planters: potting mix.

Work out the amount

All four are sold by volume, so the sum is the same: area times depth. Use the topsoil calculator for the total, then split it if you are blending. For bed-by-bed figures, see how much topsoil a raised bed needs. For a surface layer of compost, the mulch calculator works the same way.

Skip the arithmetic. Enter your measurements and get quantities in imperial or metric units.

Open the Topsoil Calculator

Monthly home energy tips

One email a month with our new guides, a free calculator to try and the latest electricity prices. Unsubscribe any time.

The signup form is provided by Hostinger Reach and loads when you click. You confirm by email before you get anything. Privacy policy.

Founder and editor, GableGreens

Muslam Uddin founded GableGreens to put plain answers and the working behind them in one place. Every guide is researched from government agencies, standards bodies and manufacturer documents, and the sums are checked before it is published. The guides are not professional advice: where a job needs a licensed electrician or engineer, the guide says so. How we research and write.